Introduction

Product recommendations have become a staple of modern retail, appearing on e-commerce sites and even in physical stores. These are the personalised suggestions like “You might also like…” or “Customers who bought this also bought…” that guide shoppers toward additional products. They are typically powered by artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms that analyse customer data – from browsing history to past purchases – to predict what each shopper is most likely to buy. The goal is simple: make the shopping experience more personal and boost sales.

Major retail success stories underscore the impact of effective product recommendations. For instance, Amazon’s recommendation engine is estimated to drive around 35% of the company’s e-commerce sales. More broadly, research has found that while only a small portion of site visitors (roughly 7%) actually click on product recommendation links, those interactions can account for about 26% of total online revenue. In other words, a well-tuned recommendation system can punch far above its weight in terms of generating sales.

Given these impressive figures, retail executives naturally want to know: Is our investment in product recommendation technology paying off? Measuring the return on investment (ROI) of product recommendations is crucial for understanding their business value. In the following sections, we explain how to define ROI in the context of retail product recommendations and which key metrics to track – from conversion rates to basket size and customer lifetime value – to gauge success. We’ll also cover how to measure and improve ROI, and best practices to maximise the benefits of personalised recommendation strategies.
‍

What Are Product Recommendations in Retail?

Product recommendations in retail are the tailored product suggestions offered to shoppers based on their likely interests. These can appear in many forms – on e-commerce sites (for example, “Recommended for you” carousels or “Frequently bought together” prompts on product pages) and even in physical stores (such as sales associates suggesting complementary items). What makes these recommendations powerful is personalisation. Instead of showing the same best-selling products to everyone, modern recommendation engines use customer data and AI to present items that each individual shopper is most likely to buy. Essentially, it’s like having a knowledgeable salesperson who knows each customer’s preferences, but automated and scalable across digital channels.
‍

Why Product Recommendations Matter for Retail ROI

Investing in product recommendation technology isn’t just a nice-to-have – it directly impacts critical business metrics. Effective recommendations improve the shopping experience and drive incremental sales, which in turn boosts ROI. Here are a few key ways that product recommendations add value:

• Higher Conversion Rates: Personalised suggestions can nudge indecisive browsers into becoming buyers. When customers see products that align with their interests or complement items they’ve already viewed, they are more likely to click “add to cart.” In fact, one analysis found that customers who clicked a recommended item were 4.5 times more likely to make a purchase during their visit than those who didn’t click any recommendations. This shows how powerful tailored recommendations can be for converting browsers into buyers.
• Larger Basket Size and Average Order Value: Product recommendations excel at upselling and cross-selling. By highlighting complementary items or premium upgrades, recommendations encourage customers to spend more per visit. For example, one baby products retailer saw a 21% jump in average order value and a 31% increase in basket size after implementing a personalised recommendation engine, as customers started adding more suggested items to their carts. Notably, nearly 49% of consumers say they have ended up buying a product they hadn’t planned to purchase because a recommendation suggested it – showing how these tools can boost incremental sales.
• Increased Customer Lifetime Value: The benefits of recommendations aren’t limited to a single transaction – they also foster customer loyalty and repeat business. By making customers feel understood, good recommendations encourage repeat purchases. For example, first-time visitors who clicked a recommendation were nearly twice as likely to return compared to those who didn’t. Over time, these effects translate into higher customer lifetime value (CLV). It’s not surprising that 91% of consumers say they are more likely to shop with brands that offer relevant recommendations.
  ‍

Understanding ROI for Product Recommendations

Return on Investment (ROI) is a financial metric used to evaluate the profitability of an investment relative to its cost. It’s typically expressed as a percentage, calculated as:

ROI = (Net Profit from the Investment ÷ Cost of the Investment) × 100%

For product recommendations, the “investment” includes the costs of the recommendation system – such as software subscription fees, integration and maintenance expenses, and any related operational costs. The “return” is the additional profit your recommendation system generates, often in the form of incremental sales that wouldn’t have happened without those personalised suggestions.

The aim is to find the incremental lift in sales generated by the recommendations – essentially, how much extra revenue the recommendation tool produces beyond what you would have sold without it. Often this requires analyzing specific performance metrics and even running tests to attribute sales uplift to recommendations.

For example, if you spend $10,000 on a product recommendation tool and it directly generates an estimated $50,000 in additional net profit, the ROI would be (50,000 ÷ 10,000) × 100% = 500% (assuming that $50,000 is net profit, not just revenue). This simple calculation implies that for every $1 spent on the recommendation technology, you earned $5 back in profit – a very strong return. (This example is simplified; in practice you’ll rely on multiple indicators and analyses to measure true ROI.) Next, let’s examine the key metrics to focus on.
‍

Key Metrics to Measure the Impact of Recommendations

To gauge the ROI of product recommendations, retailers should monitor a set of core metrics that reflect how these suggestions are influencing shopper behaviour and the bottom line. The most important metrics include conversion rate, average order value, basket size, customer lifetime value, and the share of revenue attributable to recommendations. Here’s a closer look at each:

Conversion Rate

Conversion rate is the percentage of visitors (or sessions) that result in a purchase. When evaluating product recommendations, it’s insightful to compare the conversion rates of customers who interact with recommendations versus those who don’t. A noticeably higher conversion rate among those exposed to recommendations indicates that the suggestions are effectively turning more browsers into buyers.

An analysis of shopping sessions found that conversion rates climb dramatically when customers engage with product recommendations. In sessions without any recommendation engagement, conversion rates hovered around 1%. However, after a single click on a recommended product, conversion rates jumped to nearly 4%, and continued to rise with each additional recommendation interaction. This illustrates how relevant suggestions can quickly translate into more shoppers completing purchases.

Even without a detailed breakdown, you might observe an overall uptick in your site’s conversion rate after implementing a recommendation engine. If your conversion rate rises from 2.0% to 2.5% site-wide following the introduction of personalised recommendations, that 0.5 percentage point increase represents a substantial boost in sales from the same traffic. To measure this effect precisely, you can run an A/B test – showing recommendations to one group of visitors and no recommendations to a control group – and compare the results. If the group seeing recommendations consistently converts at a higher rate (say 3% vs. 2% for the control), you can attribute that lift to the recommendations and calculate how much extra revenue it produces.

Average Order Value (AOV) and Basket Size

Average Order Value (AOV) is the average amount a customer spends per transaction, and basket size refers to the number of items in each order. Product recommendations often have a significant impact on both of these metrics by encouraging customers to discover more products and purchase additional items.

For instance, one analysis found that when a shopper clicked on a recommended product, their order value was much higher than if they hadn’t engaged with any recommendations – in that study, sessions with recommendation engagement had orders several times larger on average than those with no recommendation clicks. This makes sense: if a customer adds even one extra item due to a “You might also like” suggestion, the total value of that order goes up.

Many retailers can attest to these effects in their own data. If you observe that after deploying a recommendation engine, your AOV has increased (for example, from $50 to $60), that gain can often be credited to recommendation-fueled cross-sells and upsells. Likewise, an increase in the average number of items per order indicates that people are indeed adding those suggested products to their carts. In fact, one retailer achieved a 31% increase in items per order after introducing personalised recommendations – a clear boost to revenue per customer.

From an ROI perspective, higher AOV and larger basket sizes mean you’re generating more revenue (and profit) per transaction, which improves the return on the investment in your recommendation system.

Customer Lifetime Value and Retention

Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) is the total revenue you expect to earn from a customer over the entire span of their relationship with your business. CLV accounts for repeat purchases and longevity, making it a key indicator of long-term profitability. Product recommendations can elevate CLV by increasing customer satisfaction and encouraging repeat engagement.

We discussed earlier how recommendations can bring customers back more often – for example, nearly doubling the likelihood of a repeat visit for first-time shoppers who click on a recommendation. Another way to see this impact is through metrics like repeat purchase rate or customer retention rate (the percentage of customers who make multiple purchases). Personalised recommendations, whether on-site or through follow-up channels like email, help re-engage past shoppers by showing them new items that match their preferences. If you notice that your 6-month or 12-month repeat purchase rate climbs after implementing recommendations, that suggests the system is enhancing retention and lifetime value.

Improvements in CLV show up as increased revenue without a corresponding rise in customer acquisition costs, which is a very healthy outcome for ROI. In short, by making every customer more valuable over time, recommendations contribute heavily to the long-term return on your investment.

Revenue Attributed to Recommendations

One of the most direct ways to measure the impact of product recommendations is to track how much revenue they are responsible for. Modern e-commerce platforms and analytics tools often provide attribution reports that quantify sales from recommendation interactions. For example, you might track the total sales that occurred after a customer clicked on a recommended item, or see what percentage of your overall revenue comes from purchases of recommended products.

Industry benchmarks show that a well-implemented recommendation engine can drive a substantial portion of online sales. Retailers commonly report anywhere from 10% up to 30% of their e-commerce revenue being directly attributable to product recommendation clicks or views. By monitoring this “revenue from recommendations” metric, you gain a clear indicator of how valuable the recommendation engine is. If, say, 15% of this month’s sales came from recommendation-influenced purchases, you can compare that against the system’s cost to help calculate ROI. The key is to consider these attributed sales as incremental – in other words, sales that likely would not have happened without the recommendation – which means they are a direct payoff from your investment.

‍

Methods to Measure and Improve ROI

Tracking the right metrics is half the battle; the other half is using that information to measure ROI accurately and improve it over time. Here are some practical methods and considerations for evaluating and boosting the ROI of product recommendations:

• A/B Testing and Lift Analysis: Show recommendations to one group of customers but not to a control group, then compare conversion rates, average order value, and sales between them. The performance uplift in the test group can be attributed to the recommendations and treated as the return generated by the tool.
• Attribution Considerations: Be mindful of how you attribute sales to recommendations, especially across channels. A customer might discover a product through an online recommendation but complete the purchase later in a store (or vice versa). Whenever possible, connect those dots – for example, use loyalty program IDs or unified commerce systems to track when a recommendation in one channel leads to a sale in another. Also, remember that not every click leads to an immediate purchase – a customer might click a recommended item and buy it days later. Try to include these delayed conversions in your analysis to capture the recommendation engine’s full impact.
• Continuous Optimisation: Maximising ROI is an ongoing process. Treat your recommendation engine as a living part of your retail strategy that you continuously refine. Keep testing different recommendation strategies or settings. You might experiment with the types of recommendations shown (e.g. “top sellers” vs. “just for you” algorithms for new visitors) or adjust where and how recommendations are displayed on the site. Remove or replace poorly performing recommendation widgets and scale up the placement of well-performing ones. Even if your AI engine learns on its own, it benefits from periodic tuning. By continually refining the system and its content, you ensure that customers stay engaged with the recommendations and maintain (or even improve) the conversion and AOV boosts that drive your ROI.

‍

Best Practices to Maximise ROI from Recommendations

Finally, here are some best practices that successful retailers employ to get the most out of their product recommendations. Implementing these strategies can help ensure you achieve a high ROI:

1. Focus on Relevance: Relevance is the cornerstone of effective recommendations. Leverage as much data as you can (browsing history, past purchases, customer preferences) to inform the suggestions. AI-driven engines excel at crunching this data to deliver truly personalised results. The goal is to make each suggestion feel truly relevant to the customer, so they’re more likely to act on it.
2. Strategic Placement: Display recommendations at key points in the shopping journey where they can influence decisions. For example, show complementary item recommendations on product pages (“Complete the look” or “Works well with this”) and upsell recommendations in the cart or checkout page (“You might want to add…”). Also, pay attention to placement on the screen – recommendations that appear prominently (often above the fold on a webpage) tend to get more engagement than those buried further down. Make sure customers notice the recommendations, without overwhelming them.
3. Test and Learn: Continuously experiment to see what kind of recommendations work best. Try different approaches, such as changing the wording of recommendation headers (“Recommended for you” vs. “You may also like”) or testing different algorithms. See if showing a small number of highly relevant suggestions performs better than a longer list of options. By A/B testing these elements, you can refine the recommendation experience. This “test and learn” approach ensures your strategy keeps pace with changing customer behaviour and preferences, helping to maintain strong results (and ROI) over time.
4. Integrate Across Channels: Extend your product recommendations beyond just the website. Include personalised suggestions in marketing emails, mobile app notifications, and other customer touchpoints. For example, sending a follow-up email that highlights new items related to a customer’s recent purchase can entice them back for another sale. Retailers often find that adding product suggestions to emails or notifications increases engagement and conversion rates. And if you have physical stores, consider equipping in-store staff with digital tools that provide smart suggestions, extending personalisation into physical retail. The more consistently you deliver relevant suggestions across channels, the more opportunities you create for additional sales.
5. Monitor and Refine: Pay attention to customer feedback and behaviour around recommendations. If certain recommended products have unusually high return rates or are frequently ignored, there may be a mismatch in relevance. Similarly, if customers start to see the same suggestions too often, the recommendations could lose their effectiveness. Use these signals to adjust your approach – perhaps by updating your recommendation algorithms or refreshing the product assortment being recommended. Maintaining customer trust is important; shoppers should feel that the recommendations are genuinely helpful, not pushy. When customers trust your suggestions, they are more inclined to use them, which in turn boosts sales and ROI.

By following these best practices, retailers can create a positive feedback loop: better recommendations lead to more engagement and sales, which justifies further investment in personalisation, leading to even better recommendations. This virtuous cycle ultimately maximises the return on investment from your recommendation initiatives.

‍

Conclusion

Product recommendations have proven to be a powerful tool in retail, driving higher conversion rates, larger basket sizes, and stronger customer loyalty. Measuring the ROI of these systems is essential to ensure that your personalisation efforts are contributing to the company’s bottom line. By focusing on key metrics like conversion, AOV, and CLV – and using methods such as A/B testing and robust analytics – retail leaders can quantify the value of their recommendation strategies and make informed decisions.

Done right, product recommendations tend to pay for themselves many times over. Retailers often see substantial lifts in revenue and profitability after implementing personalised recommendation engines, with ROI figures well above 100%. However, maximising that ROI requires more than just plugging in a piece of software. It calls for thoughtful implementation, continuous optimisation, and a customer-centric approach to personalisation. Businesses that successfully leverage product recommendations will not only enjoy immediate sales boosts, but also build deeper relationships with their customers – a long-term competitive advantage that is hard to measure but invaluable.

Key Statistics

• 35% – Estimated share of Amazon’s e-commerce sales that are generated by its product recommendation engine, highlighting the value of personalised suggestions for driving revenue.
• 26% – Portion of total online revenue attributed to product recommendation engagements in one analysis (despite those recommendations accounting for only ~7% of clicks), demonstrating their outsized impact on sales.
• 4.5× – Increase in the likelihood of a purchase when a shopper clicks on a recommended product, compared to a shopper who doesn’t engage with any recommendations during a session.
• 21% & 31% – The increase in average order value and basket size, respectively, observed by one retailer after implementing an AI-driven product recommendation system (customers bought more items per order when recommendations were present).
• 2000% ROI – A reported return on investment from advanced personalisation efforts (companies seeing $20 in revenue for every $1 spent), indicating the potential payoff of effective recommendation strategies.
• 49% – Nearly half of consumers have bought a product they hadn’t initially intended to purchase because a recommendation suggested it, reflecting how recommendations can boost incremental sales.

‍